AI can be a great study buddy, but it can also quietly do the thinking for us. This exercise helps students draw a clear line: use AI to learn, not to hand in someone else’s work as your own.
At a Glance
Activity Type: Discussion and writing
Duration: 25 minutes
Class Size: Whole class, in pairs
Grades: 6-12
Learning Objectives
- Students will tell the difference between AI coaching and AI copying.
- Students will write an honest prompt that asks for help learning, not for a finished answer.
- Students will explain, in their own words, what they learned after using AI.
Materials Needed
- A short homework-style prompt on the board, such as a math word problem or a paragraph to revise
- Paper or a notebook for each student
- No student names, grades, or private information shared aloud
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Start with the line (5 minutes). Say: “AI can coach you, or it can copy for you. Coaching helps you learn. Copying means you hand in work you did not do. Today we practice the coaching side.” Ask students where they think that line falls.
- Sort the prompts (10 minutes). Read prompts aloud in pairs, such as “Write my essay for me” and “Quiz me on these five facts, one at a time, and tell me which ones I missed.” Students sort each as coach or copy, and explain why. Say: “If the prompt removes your thinking, it is copy. If it stretches your thinking, it is coach.”
- Practice a coach prompt (7 minutes). Students pick a school topic they are learning and write one coach prompt, then write what they would still have to do themselves. Say: “Good coaching still leaves the real work with you. That is the point.”
- Close with honesty (3 minutes). Say: “When you use AI for schoolwork, say so, in the way your teacher asks. Honesty about help is part of doing honest work.” Students write one sentence they could use to describe the help they got.
Discussion Questions
- When does AI help you learn faster, and when does it slow your learning down?
- Why does it matter to be honest about AI help, even if no one would notice?
- What would you do if a friend asked you to share an AI-written answer?
Assessment
Look for students sorting coach from copy with a reason, writing a coach prompt that asks for practice or feedback, and naming what they still need to do themselves. Return to the Exercise Finder for more classroom exercises.
