AI sounds confident even when it is wrong, and a wrong fact shared kindly is still a wrong fact. This exercise teaches students a quick check before they pass an AI answer along.
At a Glance
Activity Type: Discussion and sorting
Duration: 20 minutes
Class Size: Whole class, in small groups
Grades: 6-12
Learning Objectives
- Students will explain why AI answers can sound right and still be wrong.
- Students will use a three-part check: source, sense, and kindness.
- Students will decide when to hold a claim back instead of sharing it.
Materials Needed
- Four made-up AI-style claims on the board, some true-sounding and some clearly off
- Paper for each group
- No real students, teachers, or school events used as examples
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Start with confidence (5 minutes). Say: “AI can write in a confident voice, even when it makes something up. Confidence is not proof.” Ask students if they have ever seen an AI answer that felt right but was not.
- Teach the check (5 minutes). Say: “Before you share, ask three things. Source: where else can I find this? Sense: does it make sense with what I already know? Kindness: could sharing it embarrass or hurt someone if it is wrong?” Write the three questions where everyone can see them.
- Sort the claims (7 minutes). Groups sort the made-up claims into share, check first, or hold back. Say: “Holding something back is not being boring. It is being fair.” Groups explain one choice each.
- Close with a rule (3 minutes). Say: “If you cannot check it, and it could hurt someone, do not share it.” Students write the three questions on a sticky note or in a notebook for the next time they use AI.
Discussion Questions
- Why is it harder to check something that already sounds true?
- What is a kind way to correct a classmate who shared a wrong AI fact?
- When is it better to ask a teacher than to trust an AI answer?
Assessment
Look for students naming all three check questions, sorting claims with reasons, and choosing hold back for claims that could hurt someone if wrong. Return to the Exercise Finder for more classroom exercises.
